Thursday, January 15, 2009

Superplonker


Until a year or two ago, I was a Guardian reader. I'd first started reading it at art college when Pentagram and David Hillman's groundbreaking redesign brought me to it, but I stayed with it because I liked the paper's insight, balance and the genuine genius of Steve Bell. I even worked for them for a bit. A couple of years back, the Guardian stopped being merely handwringing and liberal, and became preachy and accusatory. The feeling I got was that if I didn't agree with the editorial, I must be The Enemy. Also, it seemed to me that the paper was slipping into a parody of itself. Their saturday supplement in particular only seemed to be of relevance to about 25 women who live within half a mile of Angel tube station. And then you'd get the occasional gem like the (in)famous Max Gogarty blog. Anyway, I don't read it any more.

And then you get something like This beaut from Malcolm Gluck, their extraordinarily smug wine writer, chiefly famous for his old 'Superplonk' article and website extolling the bargains to be found in the wine aisles of supermarkets.

Other than saying that pound for pound, craft beer is of a much higher quality than almost any wine, It's difficult to know where to start, so I won't bother. Just read it for yourself.

5 comments:

Affer said...

Extraordinary! The Grauniad has obviously been sending all journos on a 'Subtle Irony' course at the Jeremy Clarkson School......

TheAleReport said...

I'll give him this, though: he certainly got a lot of people talking. And it must have taken him hours to reply to all those comments.

Boak said...

Surely a deliberate windup, designed to get lots of comments?

Ten Inch Wheeler said...

Doesn't do much for his rep as a drinks writer though...

Will said...

Presumably the intent was to be tongue in cheek but the lack of real humour casts him in a very dubious light.